A letter from Pete Malinowski
Dear friends
A few months ago, our team discovered something at Soundview Park in the Bronx that I've been hoping to see for a very long time. Wild oysters were growing on reef structures we had never seeded. Nobody had put them there. They had found their way to the reef on their own, settled, and begun to grow. I've spent most of my life around oysters, and I can tell you that finding them there meant more to me than I can easily put into words. After years of trying to create the right conditions for life to return to New York Harbor, we were seeing the Harbor begin to do some of that work itself.
We started building the reef at Soundview six years ago, alongside students who helped weld structures, dive the site, and collect data alongside our team. It was not a straightforward process. Nothing is in restoration like this. We tested different approaches and watched some fail. We removed structures that couldn't withstand the conditions, and kept returning to try again. This year, we saw some remarkable results. Oysters on our newer structures had grown to nearly three inches in just 14 months. They were mature and spawning, disease levels were low, and wild oysters were settling on the reef without our intervention. After years of work, these were the signs we'd been hoping to find.
To understand why that matters, you have to understand what this Harbor once was. For thousands of years, the Lenape lived alongside and harvested from an estuary filled with oyster reefs. New York eventually became one of the world's great oyster-producing cities, supported by an extraordinary natural abundance that most of us can scarcely imagine today. But overharvesting, pollution, and the transformation of the waterfront took their relentless toll. Within generations, the reefs had largely disappeared, and the Harbor became a place many New Yorkers learned to avoid rather than explore. As some naturalists say in the city, New Yorkers truly turned their backs on the Harbor. We lost more than oysters. We sincerely lost a connection to the natural world that had helped shape this city from its very beginning.
When we started Billion Oyster Project, we wanted to challenge the idea that this loss was permanent. We believed that New York Harbor could once again support thriving oyster reefs, and that the people growing up around it should have a hand in bringing them back. But believing something is possible and knowing how to make it happen are very different things. The work at Soundview has given us reason for real optimism, real hope. And of course, a clearer understanding of how much remains to be done. Although the oysters are growing and reproducing, natural recruitment is not yet sufficient to sustain these small reefs over time. If we want oyster populations that can endure for generations, we need to restore habitat on a much larger scale and begin reconnecting the places where oysters can live and reproduce throughout the Harbor.
That is the challenge we're preparing to take on in 2027. At Head of Bay in Jamaica Bay, we plan to restore 47 million oysters, drawing on the lessons we've learned at Soundview and across more than a decade of restoration work. The scale is ambitious, but it reflects how our understanding of this ecosystem has evolved. We're no longer simply asking whether oysters can survive in New York Harbor. We're working to understand what it will take for them to thrive here again, with less and less help from us over time.
As much as I care about the oysters, I think just as often about the young people who are growing up alongside this work. I've watched students who had never thought much about the water surrounding their city become completely absorbed in what they find beneath its surface. I've seen them take on the difficult, sometimes messy work of asking heavy-hitting questions, collecting data, and trying to understand why something succeeds or fails. These experiences can change the way a young person sees New York, but they can also change the way they see themselves. The Harbor becomes more than scenery or something to cross on the way to somewhere else. It becomes a place they know, care about, and have helped shape.
That's why our education work has always been inseparable from restoration. This year, we engaged 24,104 students through our programs, and as we prepare to expand access through our new partnership with NYC Ferry and the New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC), called the Floating Classroom, I keep thinking about how many New York City children have grown up within sight of the water without ever having the opportunity to experience it firsthand. I want those young people to know the Harbor as an active part of their city, and to grow up with the understanding that its future is something they can influence. Whether they become scientists, teachers, engineers, artists, or something entirely different, that sense of connection can stay with them.
Looking back on this year, I'm proud that our restoration work has reached 19.58 acres of reef and that our scientists documented 66 marine species around our reefs. I'm proud of the thousands of students who have explored the Harbor with us and the many people who have given their time, expertise, and support to make this work possible. But what I’m thankful for the most is the relationship between those accomplishments. Every reef we build creates new opportunities for marine life, and every young person who experiences the Harbor has an opportunity to develop a lasting connection to the natural world around them. We're rebuilding an ecosystem, but we're also helping New York rediscover something fundamental about itself.
This has always been a city shaped by water, and its future depends in part on how well we stand up for it.
None of this has happened quickly, and none of it would have happened without people like you. You've supported work that requires patience, experimentation, and the willingness to keep going even when progress is difficult to see. Your generosity continues to help us bring more young New Yorkers onto the water, and continue the long work of restoring the Harbor we all share.
I often wonder what New York Harbor will look like fifty years from now. My hope is that the reefs we're building today will be part of a much larger, self-sustaining ecosystem, one that no longer depends on people like us to keep putting oysters in the water. And I hope that the children growing up in this city will know the Harbor so well, and care about it so deeply, that they cannot imagine New York without its extraordinary natural life. That's the future we're working toward, and I'm deeply grateful that you're helping us get there.
With gratitude,
Pete Malinowski
Pete Malinowski
CEO & Co-Founder